Most Loved Orange Beach & Gulf Shores Restaurants (+ our picks)

Whether you are heading to the Alabama Beaches for summer fun or off-season relaxation, there are some Orange Beach and Gulf Shores restaurants that just shouldn’t be skipped. Breakfast? Date Night? Sweet Tooth? Whatever you desire, we have you covered.

There wasn’t time for Sue and I to visit ALL the Gulf Shores restaurants, as well as all the Orange Beach restaurants during our visits. But we did amass a great checklist of top picks from the greater community that we’ll be working down on subsequent trips. We’ll start with the local’s favorites, then we’ll tell you our top picks.

 

Places to Eat in Gulf Shores Where the Locals Hang Out

We mentioned on Facebook this was our first visit to the the Alabama beaches and holy cow did the community come through with suggestions for the best Gulf Shores restaurants, as well as the best places to eat in Orange Beach. We boiled it down to these favorites.

LuLu’s Gulf Shores Restaurant (Gulf Shores). According to our sources, Lulu’s has some of the best food in Gulf Shores and is great for kids (hello am entire kids play area.) And if you have a food allergy, there is a special menu just for you. See Lesli review below.

Hangout (Gulf Shores). A definate favorite with our Facebook friends. Lives bands. Renown festivals  (see Lesli’s review below of the Oyster Cook-off), daiquiri bar, and so much for the kids. The locals tipped us off to a Pirates and Princess breakfast, as well as the fact there are…. “bubbles for days so put them in their swimsuits.”

The Original Oyster House. (Gulf Shores). This may be a waterfront seafood restaurant, but our contacts can’t leave without a whole key lime pie. Word has it you should check out the little shops around too.

Shrimp Basket. (Gulf Shores restaurant) This is a local chain that is in both Gulf Shores and Orange Beach.

King Neptunes (Gulf Shores). This is a small local joint run by Gulf Coast native Al Sawyer. In fact, you’ll likely find him hanging out around lunch time with some great stories. Oh, and our readers said he has the best crab claws in town. And you can’t leave without trying the fried cheesecake.

Sea-n-Suds. (Gulf Shores) You don’t even have to leave the beach to grab a cold brew and some local seafood at Sea-n-Suds. It’s been a Gulf Shores beach tradition for more than 43 years.

Tacky Jacks. (Several Locations)  You are getting the Bushwacker with apps and a beautiful view according to our Facebook friends.This place looks like a kids colorful erector set. We hit Tacky Jack’s for breakfast at the Fort Morgan location. The newest spot is in Gulf Shores where it sits among old oak trees directly on the Intracoastal Waterway. Ask the server for a piece of tape to leave your mark at this iconic Orange Beach and Gulf Shores restaurant.

Bahama Bob’s Beachside Cafe. (Gulf Shores) A little seafood shack on the water. Get your Caribbean on here.

Pink Pony World Famous Beach Bar. (Gulf Shores) The Pink Pony in Atlanta means something totally different and I almost left this off because of that, but, apparently the highlight of this late night party spot is karaoke.

Bill’s By the Beach. (Gulf Shores) This Gulf Shores restaurant serves coastal comfort food made with fresh ingredients. They are also know for burgers and Sunday brunch. Keep the kids busy while they wait at the children’s play area underneath the restaurant.

Hopes Cheesecake. (Gulf Shores) Cheesecake by the slice or whole. Eat in for amazing views.

Fish River Grill. (Gulf Shores) Wondering where to eat in Gulf Shores that has lots of locals hanging out? According to our sources, it’s here.

De Soto’s Seafood Kitchen. (Gulf Shores) This Gulf Shores restaurant is locally owned and operated and been a tradition for families vacationing, as well as locals.

Mikees. (Gulf Shores) This locally owned Gulf Shores restaurant doesn’t look like anything fancy from the outside, but our Facebook friends said the food is worth a visit.

Flying Harpoon. (Gulf Shores) This Gulf Shores restaurant (a second location was added in Orange Beach) is a local favorite, and a recommendation from our boat captain. The roast beef po’boy is HUGE, so plan to split with a friend. Good fried shrimp and handmade potato chips.

Sunliner Diner. (Gulf Shores) Need a break from seafood?  The Sunliner Diner is a good choice with solid food and a pretty impressive dessert menu that includes those over the top milkshakes the Alabama Coast is known for. Ask if you can sit in the convertible car booth.

Local Favorite Restaurants in Orange Beach AL

Fin and Fork. (Orange Beach) Several folks on our Facebook page recommended this Orange Beach restaurant. Our boat captain said this is one of her favorite places to eat and she highly recommends brunch too – especially the crabmeat stuffed snapper.

Doc’s Seafood Shack and Oyster Bar (Orange Beach restaurant). Voted a Top 10 seafood shack in America by Fox News. But more telling, it was voted five emoji hearts in our Facebook thread. And I love the billboard “best shrimp in the civilized world.” I mean, who wouldn’t want the best shrimp in the civilized world.

Gulf Shore Steamer. (Orange Beach) On your way toward FL on the left before the bridge  (you can’t miss the big silver fish statue) is Gulf Shore Steamers where they serve broiled and grilled catches. The Royal Reds are yummy. Hand cut steak and fresh fish are on the menu as well. Another locally owned restaurant operated by Ashley Ouellette, say hi when you visit.

SALT. (Orange Beach). According to our FB friends – Best. Steak. Ever.

Louisiana Lagniappe. (Orange Beach) This Orange Beach restaurant is a little bit of New Orleans on the coast.

Playa. (Orange Beach) Conch fritters, grilled swordfish, steak tacos. You can’t go wrong here according to our associates.

Flippers. (Orange Beach) Live music and an outdoor tiki bar.Well. Ok.

Luna’s Eat & Drink. (Orange Beach) One of the largest offerings of craft beer on the island, plus fresh seafood and simple ingredients.

GT’s on the Bay. (Orange Beach) The tip we received – the food is fabulous, so are drinks. GT’s has Bayside dining and a menu that includes seafood, as well as stone hearth pizza. There is even a large fish pond to keep the kids entertained while they wait.

Cobalt Restaurant. (Orange Beach) Go by land or go by sea, just make sure you go. In addition to the recommendations for the food, our sources like this Orange Beach restaurant  for it’s expansive deck.

Fisher’s Dockside. (Orange Beach) I didn’t get a lot from the person that recommended Fishers, just that it was good. Do you know more? Tell me. I think there is also a fine dining option upstairs.

Blue Water BBQ. (Orange Beach) There are several BBQ joints in Orange Beach. This is a fairly new one located at The Wharf. Although you may think brisket is more a Texas thing, Blue Water does a pretty good job.

Lamberts. (Foley) So technically this is just a restaurant near Gulf Shores and Orange Beach, but it sounds fun. Always a wait, but worth it according to our sources. Stay alert when eating at this comfort food establishment. They throw the rolls. Yes, the waiters chuck the rolls across the dining room to your waiting hand.

Orange Beach restaurants

365 Atlanta Traveler Picks

We at 365 Atlanta Traveler have only skimmed the surface of the best restaurants in Gulf Shores AL and Orange Beach, which is why we looked to our FB audience to help us with this post.  However, based on our experience, here are our picks (subject to change with future visits) of 11 must-visit eateries on the gorgeous white sands of the gulf, plus a foodie festival you MUST add to your bucket list!

For The First Time Visitor

LuLu’s Gulf Shores. (Gulf Shores restaurant) Let me be honest – I was nervous about going here. I was sure it was just a tourist trap…I mean, every one always mentions it, right? But OMG! It was so fun and amazing – and filled with locals – and offered delicious food. So don’t skip this dining destination. It lives up to the hype.

We visited off-season, so there was not a crowd. We did notice that there were plenty of things to do if you find yourself waiting in line…games outside (like rings and cornhole,) a gift shop, photo ops, spike ball and plenty of space to roam with a drink while you wait for a table.

We also enjoyed live music on our visit. Though we were near the band, the noise level was perfect (and the band was super!)

Start with the smoked tuna dip, served with crackers. It’s delicious.

Kid’s meals are only $6 – both boys went for the burger and give it a thumbs up when paired with the fries. Fish, chicken, and other options are also available.

I picked the shrimp and grits – two servers told me it was their favorite selection, and now I know why! Besides the shrimp, this dish includes bites of andouille sausage with a tasso ham gravy served over gouda grits. YUM!

For those who aren’t aware, Lucy (aka LuLu) is Jimmy Buffet’s sister…so we couldn’t visit without having a margarita!!

I highly recommend a stop here when you visit Orange Beach. I’m so glad we did it!

Flora Bama. (Pensecola) This is technically a restaurant NEAR Orange Beach, BUT it’s an institution, so I included it. Everyone has to go at least once (or if you are with my husband, numerous times).

Listen to bands. Watch them play volleyball on the beach. Enjoy the famous Bushwacker. (you’ll see those a lot at ALL the Orange Beach and Gulf Shores restaurants) And just so you know what you are getting into, the place looks like it’s held together with plywood and duck tape. Before 9 pm you’ll see lots of kids in here too.

The Gulf. (Orange Beach restaurant) Another great place to hang out that couldn’t be more different than the Flora Bama. There are two kitchens on either side of this quick serve Orange Beach restaurant made from shipping containers.

One is a taco bar, the other offers chef selections. There is a cute shop and two bars in-between. But the real star of the show is the dining room, which is completely outside on the beach. Kids and adults never tire of seeing the boats coming through the channel. This is classic Orange Beach dining.

Can’t Beat Lunch Spot

Anchor Bar & Grill. (Orange Beach) The menu description – fish tacos made with chipolte seared grey tilefish, with a black lime creamed corn, tamarind poblano salsa with a pickled onion and cotja. My description – Delicious! Just enough spice. The creamed corn is so fresh. The tilefish is meaty and cooked perfectly. This was the best food we had in Orange Beach. Actually, it was probably the best fish tacos I’ve ever had…Period!

If you want these fish tacos, get here fast, the menu has only eight items and changes often. Our local CVB contact raved about the creative Bushwacker drinks too. Check out their Instagram for a few samples. 

I love the Hudson Marina location as well. They have picnic tables that are literally IN the water. If we hadn’t just biked 12 miles to get there, it would have been fun to sit in the sun.

And the staff is just as impressive as the food. Our waiter raved about his colleagues in the kitchen, and the alumni who are now sous chefs at The Staple House in Atlanta, which is rated one of the top 10 restaurants in the city.

For The Champion Breakfast Lover

The Ruby Slipper(Orange Beach Restaurant) The Ruby Slipper is known for their amazing breakfasts and brunches. This restaurant hails from NOLA and you can tell that in the menu…there’s a bit of creole in almost every selection.

There are plenty of things to grab from this breakfast menu…The Costa Rican (black beans & rice over a tomato salsa, two eggs and spicy chorizo sausage) or the Bananas Foster…maybe the Louisiana omelette or a Creole Reuben…but for me, the pista la resistance were the Benedicts.

There are six Benedicts to choose from, featuring shrimp, pork, corned beef, chicken, salmon…but if you’re indecisive like us, then get the Peacemaker.  It allows you to mix and match two of any of the selections.

Pictured above are the Eggs Cochon (Slow-cooked, apple-braised pork) and the Chicken St Charles (Fried chicken breast finished with a pork tasso cream sauce.) Both were mouth-watering, but the crispy crust and juicy cut of the chicken was my favorite. And tasso cream over a poached egg may be my newest vice. WOW!

The Bloody Mary here was the best one I found on our visit. Maybe it was their award-winning mix, or maybe it was the bacon-infused vodka. Either way, I will return to The Ruby Slipper again and again.

Oh! And bring the kids. Our little ones adored the Cinnamon Sugar French Toast Batons, which were stacked like Jenga pieces high on their plate!

Southern Grind.  (Orange Beach) This funky coffee shop has two locations in Orange Beach, one located in The Wharf and the other in the Hotel Indigo.

We visited the Wharf location. Leave time to shop before or after your meal. I came away with the need for a necklace and a painting. If only I could have gotten the painting in the car for the way home.

But I digress, we’re here to talk about the food. I ordered a standard breakfast biscuit with fluffy eggs, crispy bacon, smothered in cheese on a true southern biscuit – because why would you choose the ‘other’ bread.

It was delicious, but I had a bit of entree envy. My companions ordered very different items. A mozzarella, tomato & basil scramble with bacon that was a weight watchers approved and a delicious looking dish. I kinda wished I had ‘gone healthy.’

The other was anything but weight watchers approved and perfect for vacation. A Belgain waffle with strawberries & cream. The strawberries and the raspberry drizzle made it pretty and then there was fruit… right.

City Donut. (Orange Beach) Looking for something quick, try City Donut for both over the top and standard yeast and cake donuts. Go early though, there are no pre-made donuts here, all are baked fresh each morning, and when they are gone, they are gone.

Courtesy of Voyagers

For The Most Romantic Date Night

Voyagers. (Orange Beach) We ditched the kids one night to enjoy some time alone, with a date night dinner at this romantic escape within the Perdido Beach Resort. No – we were not staying here…that isn’t necessary for a visit.

Be sure to make a reservation and plan for an unhurried, two-hour culinary vacation. This quiet retreat tucked in a popular beach resort can ‘sit at the table’ with James Beard award-winning restaurants in any large city. The food was top-notch; the service was high class; the wine selection was impeccable; and the view was gorgeous.

Start with the oysters…I enjoyed the Rockefellers with Swiss chard, but my favorite were the Bienville, which included shrimp and crab, covered in a savory mornay sauce.

Seafood not your thing? The charcuterie board is also a smart selection, with local cheese and meats. We especially enjoyed the accompanying chutneys and sauces.

Main selections include meats, chicken and seafood. From the red meat category, Hubby went with the Veal Short Rib, which had been braised in red wine for several days. Divine.

I couldn’t be at the beach without taking advantage of the seafood, so I selected the Swordfish, which was caramelized with root veggies and sitting on a beautiful wedge of ham and polenta gratin. It was so rich and juicy…so delicious.

And don’t skip dessert. You’ll be full…it’s a ton of amazing food. But take a moment, enjoy a cup of coffee, and then order that dessert. Imagine spice cake with cafe con leche mousse and spiced caramel. Or bread pudding with caramelized apples and a white chocolate bourbon custard. Mmmmm.

When your coffee is gone and you’ve eaten the last bite of spice cake, don’t miss the opportunity to pop out to the beach and enjoy the full moon over the gulf.

 

For The Bloody Mary Connoisseur

Brick & Spoon. (Orange Beach) I knew I was going to like this place when I pulled up and the sign read, “Bloody Mary. Because adulting is hard.”

Then, inside, when the waitress handed me a Build Your Own Bloody Mary Menu…well, that’s when I fell in love. Pick your vodka, pick the heat level, add veggies, meats, and all the garnishments your heart desires.

And she’s not just a pretty face…that drink was pure joy. Delicious! Best part? This isn’t Georgia, so we enjoyed this beauty on a Sunday morning well before 12:30! There are no Sunday liquor laws here.

As for the food…also great. I enjoyed my American Breakfast with eggs, bacon, etc…but I coveted hubby’s selection. He picked the Breakfast Taco, and wow, I still have dreams about those!

The shell isn’t a typical crispy corn wrapper – it’s a light, flaky wonton shell, filled with chorizo eggs and cheddar jack cheese – with a perfect mango salsa. Oh my!

You’ll notice a nod to New Orleans here, much like The Red Slipper, so it was no surprise to see beignets on the menu…something my boys noticed immediately. And devoured!

Photo from Yard Milkshake Bar Facebook

For Those With A Sweet Tooth

The Yard Milkshake Bar. (Gulf Shores) Let’s start with the need-to-know. You’re going to have to stand in line for a while…and then wait for your dessert for a while…even in the off-season.

It will be worth every minute.

Bring a game for the kids. Maybe a card game or some coloring books. But don’t use that as an excuse not to go.

When you do finally make it near the front of the line, you’ll mark your order on a menu using a wax pencil…picking your ice cream flavors, toppings, cookie dough selections, and more.

Or you can do what we did and pick a pre-compiled selection.

We opted for the Caramel Cheesecake Cookie Monster. It’s Salted Caramel ice cream topped with whipped cream, a slice of New York Cheesecake and caramel drizzle. Oh – plus there is a chocolate icing dipped along the top of the souvenir jar that you get to bring home with you.

One hour in line…15 minutes for four of us to guzzle this masterpiece.

And yes, I’d do it again.

CoastAL Ice Cream Company. (Gulf Shores, AL) If you don’t have the time or patience to wait in an hour or more line, head to CoastAL Ice Cream. They offer the same type of mason jar milkshakes. They don’t have the variety of Yard Milkshake Bar, but they don’t have the wait either. (at least not yet)

We chose the cookies and cream milkshake. It came with three scoops of cookie dough ice cream, served in a fudge topped mason jar (rolled in cookie crumbs) with whipped cream drizzled with chocolate sauce, and a hunk of cookie dough the size of a large cookie.  Plan to share. Even this ice cream lover found this to be a whole lotta sweet.

For The Food Festival Fanatic

Oyster Cook-Off at The Hangout. (Gulf Shores) The Hangout Oyster Cook-Off & Craft Beer Weekend is an annual festival that allows chefs from around the Southeast to show off their talents with oysters and Bloody Marys.

This year chefs competed for the best recipes in the categories of Rockefeller, Gulf Coast Cajun and Raw Oysters…and the best part? We were able to sample everything! Tasting tickets were $1 each, and a single ticket allowed you to sample the oysters, organized in booths outside of The Hangout.

We didn’t make it to Friday night’s festivities, which also included dozens of micro-brews, with unlimited tastings and live music. But we DID enjoy sampling wares from the Bloody Mary Invitational. WOW!!

There was also a raw bar, a shucking contest, and plenty of other food and fun happening inside The Hangout. We also really enjoyed the Cooking Demos from famous local and TV chefs.

Truth time. This was SUPPOSED to be a date night weekend for me and hubby, but we had some logistical issues at the last minute. It wasn’t really an issue. Kids are free…and while there are no “kid” activities, it’s pretty family friendly. They don’t eat oysters, but they just played a little Pokemon Go and ate gelato while we sampled the good stuff.

 

My friend Tamara has a few more ideas: check them out here.

 

Pin This Post

Heading to the Alabama Beaches? We surveyed locals for the most loved Gulf Shores & Orange Beach restaurants + we added our favorite picks to this comprehensive list.

 

Heading to the Alabama Beaches? We surveyed locals for the most loved Orange Beach & Gulf Shores restaurants + we added our favorite picks to this comprehensive list.

 

Disclosure: Thank you to #VisitAlabamaBeaches for hosting my family and me on our first visit to the Gulf Shores. All opinions here are our own. We LOVED this area, the food, and the beach…and can’t wait to go back again and again!

20 Comments on "Most Loved Orange Beach & Gulf Shores Restaurants (+ our picks)"

  1. Gary Bowers | 11/22/2017 at 3:35 pm | Reply

    The Sea n’ Suds is my all time favorite.

  2. Good information for locals

  3. Hayley Everitt | 01/04/2018 at 11:20 am | Reply

    I grew up in Gulf Shores and one of my personal favorites that is a complete hole in the wall and the atmosphere isn’t awesome but the food is amazing is Fish River Grill. Its off of HWY 59 in a shopping center so its hard to spot from the road and its not directly on the beach. But this is where locals eat because the food is great! My personal favorite is the Cajun Pistol Basket. The Cajun Pistol is like etouffee in a roll and then baked. If you haven’t tried this place go! I always opt for Lunch at Fish River Grill.

  4. Rick Mamrock | 08/09/2018 at 4:13 pm | Reply

    We have tried a lot of the places in gulf shores you have listed. The one that wasn’t to good was the sunliner diner. Now I understand that it had just opened. Mu daughter had an egg dish that was ice cold when she got it. I had eggs benedict and the bread it was served on was too salty. It also took awhile to get waited on and served. It looked like a cool place. That was the reason we tried it. Maybe in time it will get better.

  5. Don Bekurs | 08/09/2018 at 7:37 pm | Reply

    I’m a real estate broker and have lived in gulf shores 15 years. I eat out every day, entertain clients and talk to lots of tourists who in restaurants. In my opinion you have gotten some very bad information. Your list is almost upside down. Almost.

  6. Lol. Locals dont eat at Lulu’s or The Hangout. They are both overpriced tourists traps. Sea n Suds is my favorite. Also the Florabama isnt in Pensacola. It’s in Orange Beach & Perdido Key!! Hence the name FloraBama!!plus you left off do really good ones like Pirates Cove, Cosmo’s, Luna’s & Big Fish!!!

  7. Lol…none of these restaurants are where true locals eat. Everyone of these restaurants are designed and built with tourists in mind….not locals!!!!!

    • Nell Saunders | 08/10/2018 at 8:46 pm | Reply

      Doc’s Seafood in Orange Beach….Well, that is truly where our local’s and local workers eat lunch.

    • Sue Rodman | 08/12/2018 at 10:06 am | Reply

      So tell us TB – What did we get wrong? These were the places folks recommended on FB as their favorites – we’d love to hear yours.

  8. Most of these places are for tourists and charge accordingly. I DO agree with Fish River Grill!!! Also, what about Sunset Corkroom Grill??? Great food, but make a reservation!

  9. How could you leave off Buns in the Sun in Orange Beach? Check us out of Facebook, Yelp, Trip Advisor & Google.

  10. You left out the best food.. Flora Bama Yacht Club!

  11. How about Acme in Gulf Shores great grilled oysters!!!

  12. I love the milk shake here. It tastes a little bit like yolk shake with milk and cream in Vietnam

  13. Jane Kyburz | 09/10/2018 at 9:21 pm | Reply

    We are not exactly locals, but have had a condo down there for 35 years. We are excited to try some of the places you mentioned as we are always looking for new places. Of course, all of these reflect someone ‘s “favorite!” And I certainly understand that. Some that you mentioned are very touristy and some are not appropriate for children- not even tweens! You did leave off one of our favorites- Cosmos, but I realize the same people own Cobalt and maybe you thought that a repeat. Sea and Suds is one of our favorites for over 35 years and Lulu’s and Hangout are a little touristy! But we certainly enjoy the area! Thanks for featuring it!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*